Our Staff

Chris Pappenfus

Senior Pastor

I was raised in the Evangelical Covenant Church, coming to faith in Christ Jesus at a young age, I am grateful for the many Jesus followers who have helped nurture my faith.  I met my wife,  Allison, while serving at a Covenant Church in New England.  We were married in 2001, and have three boys, Ryan,  Brendan, and Micah.   I have served Covenant Churches in New Hampshire, Minnesota and Nebraska in a variety of ministry roles.  I was called to serve as Senior Pastor of First Covenant Willmar in the summer of 2017.  Philippians 2 is an important Scripture for me as I try to walk in obedience to the calling the LORD has extended to me.  I am humbled and grateful to be a part of this wonderful congregation that is First Covenant Church.

Stephanie Carlson

Children's & Family Ministries Director

I have been serving on the ministry staff at FCC since 2016, beginning as the Office Administrator. I’m no stranger to the Willmar community, as I was born and raised here. I ventured away for a decade, pursuing college studies in Elementary and Special Education, and worked in the St. Cloud area.
My husband, Andrew and I were married in 2014 and we are the proud parents of twin daughters, Lillian and Evelynn. I am a homeschool mom, who loves a good DIY project, long conversations with girlfriends, and singing.

Rocky Hovda

Youth & Young Adults Director

I have been active in ministry since the early 1980’s where my journey began with  inviting friends to AWANA.   I spent 16 years working as summer staff at Camp Lebanon,  with roles that  ranged from dish washer to counselor to program host. I graduated from Bethel College in 1996 and began ministry as a Youth Pastor @ Community Covenant in Upsala  for 10 years.  In 2007, my next adventure took me to First Covenant in WIllmar , MN,  working with youth and young adults. My favorite things include hosting people, making them eat food and play games; collecting comics and memorabilia; Superheroes; disc golf; volleyball; and serving Jesus!

Stephanie Tollefsrud

Worship Art's Director

Music and ministry have always been a significant part of Stephanie Tollefsrud’s story.  She received her Bachelor’s Degree in Music Education from Concordia College and her Master’s Degree in Instrumental Conducting from SCSU.  She has been blessed to serve as the director of Worship Arts and Outreach at FCC since February of 2026.  

She met her husband Lee through Joppa Christian fellowship in Willmar back in 2001 and they have been married since 2004.  When they are not busy on their farm north of Murdock, they enjoy spending quality time with family and friends.  If they are not connecting with or helping others in this community, they love to travel as often as possible to Roatan, Honduras where they continue to serve through Sandy Bay Lighthouse Ministries.

Stephanie’s life verse is Exodus 15:2 “The Lord is my strength and my song; He has become my salvation!”

Jen Elise

Office Manager

FCC Leadership

Church Chairman: Mike Buer
Vice Chairman: Gary Dahlberg
Treasurer: Cheri Baron
Corporate Secretary: Cory Jorschumb
Financial Secretary: Laura Hendrickson
Recording Secretary: Rebecca Lawton
Buildings & Grounds: John Shumlansky
Congregational Life: Marlene Hovland
Elder's Commission: Lois Dunne
Finance Commission: Bill Cairns
HR & Doc. Commission: Alan Moll
Make & Deepen Disciples: Kim Shumlansky
Mission Commission: Stacey Jorschumb
Worship Arts: Alvin Picconatto